Australian Ethical vs Future Super (2026): Fees & Returns
Australian Ethical vs Future Super: fees at five balances from the 1 Nov 2026 PDSs, returns, APRA's performance test, default insurance and who each suits.
Quick answer: On their own disclosure documents dated 1 November 2026, Australian Ethical's Balanced option is cheaper than Future Super's Sustainable Balanced Growth at every balance: $653 against $710 a year on $50,000, and $1,238 against $1,360 on $100,000. Australian Ethical also has the longer, regulator-tested track record. Its MySuper option passed APRA's 2026 performance test, while Future Super's options sit outside the test and all launched in May 2025. Future Super's case is its screening (it avoids fossil fuels, gambling, tobacco, nuclear and weapons) and its climate focus. Note that it gives you no default insurance.
Both are specialist ethical funds, so every option they offer is screened. That's the main difference from the sustainable options inside big industry funds, which our ethical super funds comparison covers. This page goes deeper on the two specialists head to head.
Fees compared at five balances
Both funds charge a flat dollar fee plus percentage fees. The flat fee matters most on small balances, and the percentage fees matter more as your balance grows. The figures below use each fund's main diversified option and come straight from the fees section of each product disclosure statement (PDS).
| Fee | Australian Ethical: Balanced | Future Super: Sustainable Balanced Growth |
|---|---|---|
| Administration (dollar) | $68 a year | $60 a year |
| Administration (percentage) | 0.25% | 0.36% |
| Investment fees and costs | 0.86% (includes 0.03% performance fees) | 0.91% (estimated) |
| Transaction costs | 0.06% | 0.03% (estimated) |
| Buy–sell spread | 0.05% / 0.05% | 0.02% / 0.02% |
| Cost on $50,000 (PDS example) | $653 | $710 |
Applying those fees to other balances, for someone holding only that one option and no insurance:
| Balance | Australian Ethical: Balanced | Future Super: Sustainable Balanced Growth | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| $10,000 | $185 | $190 | $5 |
| $25,000 | $361 | $385 | $24 |
| $50,000 | $653 | $710 | $57 |
| $100,000 | $1,238 | $1,360 | $122 |
| $250,000 | $2,993 | $3,310 | $317 |
Three points sit behind these numbers:
- The gap widens with your balance. Future Super's total percentage fees are 1.30% a year against 1.17% for Australian Ethical. Its lower $60 flat fee only helps below about $6,000.
- Australian Ethical passes on a tax rebate. It says its Balanced option costs $576 on $50,000 after a tax rebate on certain fees, against the $653 headline. Future Super's PDS doesn't quote an after-rebate figure, so the like-for-like comparison is the $653 against $710 above.
- Fees have just gone up. Both PDSs are dated 1 November 2026. The earlier documents put the same two options at $633 and $690.50 on $50,000, so check the current PDS before you compare against older reviews.
Both funds refund fees above 3% of your balance if it's under $6,000 at the end of the financial year, a rule that applies to all super funds.
See what a fee gap of $100 or more a year adds up to by retirement with our Superannuation Calculator.
Advertisement
Returns and APRA's performance test
APRA's annual performance test compares each tested product's net return over up to 10 years with a benchmark for its asset mix, plus its admin fees. The two funds sit on opposite sides of this test.
Australian Ethical's MySuper option is tested, and passed in 2026. In APRA's 2026 Comprehensive Product Performance Package, the fund's MySuper product (its Balanced option) returned 7.51% a year over 10 years to 30 June 2026. That's 0.44% a year above APRA's benchmark for its asset mix. Its choice options, Growth and Conservative, also passed.
Future Super's options aren't tested. APRA classifies them as externally directed products: diversified options where the trustee doesn't set the asset allocation or manage the investments. Under APRA's rules these aren't subject to the performance test, and APRA's 2026 data publishes no 10-year returns for them.
The funds' own published returns:
| Option | 1 year | 3 years (p.a.) | 5 years (p.a.) | 10 years (p.a.) | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Australian Ethical Balanced | 2.7% | 9.2% | 4.6% | 6.9% | To 31 Oct 2026, after all fees and taxes, on a $50,000 balance |
| Future Super Sustainable Balanced Growth | 2.49% | n/a | n/a | n/a | To 30 Sep 2026, after investment fees and taxes but before admin fees. Launched 24 May 2025 (5.08% p.a. since then) |
The two rows use different dates and bases, so treat them as a guide only. A one-year return also says little about a super fund. The bigger point is the track record: Australian Ethical's Balanced option dates back to 1998, while all five of Future Super's current options launched on 24 May 2025, when its earlier options closed.
Investment options and what each avoids
| Australian Ethical | Future Super | |
|---|---|---|
| Number of options | 7: Defensive, Conservative, Conservative Balanced, Balanced, Growth, Australian Shares, International Shares | 5: Sustainable Moderate, Sustainable Balanced Growth, Sustainable Alternatives Growth, Sustainable Growth, Sustainable High Growth |
| If you don't choose | You go into Balanced, its APRA-authorised MySuper option | You must pick an option to join. It isn't a MySuper product |
| Main option's growth assets | Balanced: 66–86% (target mix includes 15% property and infrastructure) | Sustainable Balanced Growth: 55–80% (benchmark 70%) |
| Return target | Balanced: inflation + 3.25% a year over 10 years | Sustainable Balanced Growth: inflation + 2.75% a year over rolling 10 years |
| Screening approach | The Australian Ethical Charter, unchanged since 1986, is written into the trustee's and investment manager's constitutions. Details are in its Ethical Guide | Avoids fossil fuels, gambling, tobacco, nuclear and weapons, plus positive screening and impact investing. Details are in its Product & Screening Matrix |
| Certifications and giving | RIAA-certified options. The parent was the first ASX-listed company to become a certified B Corporation (2014), and gives 10% of after-tax profits to its charitable foundation | — |
Future Super lets you split your balance across options, with at least 5% in each option you pick. Both funds publish their portfolio holdings, so you can check what each actually owns rather than relying on the label.
Advertisement
Insurance and who runs each fund
This is where the two differ most for younger members.
- Australian Ethical gives you default cover. You automatically get death and total and permanent disablement (TPD) cover once you're 25 or older and your balance reaches $6,000, unless your account has been inactive for 16 months or you've cancelled it. Premiums come out of your balance. Income protection is available on application.
- Future Super gives you no default cover. Insurance is opt-in only: eligible members can apply for death, TPD and income protection. That keeps your balance higher if you already have cover elsewhere, but leaves you uninsured if you assumed your super came with it.
The ownership structures differ too:
| Australian Ethical | Future Super | |
|---|---|---|
| Trustee | Australian Ethical Superannuation Pty Ltd, a wholly owned subsidiary of the investment manager | Stewarda Pty Ltd, as trustee of the Smart Future Trust |
| Investment manager | Australian Ethical Investment Ltd, listed on the ASX (AEF) | Future Group Investment Management, part of Future Group |
| Size | 98,770 MySuper accounts at 30 June 2026 (APRA) | "50,000+ members" as at September 2026 (Future Super) |
Future Super is a product within a larger multi-product trust run by a separate trustee company. Australian Ethical owns its own trustee. Neither structure is unsafe: both are APRA-regulated. But with Future Super, the company you see (Future Super) isn't the trustee legally responsible for your money. Future Super's admin fee does include access to intra-fund coaching on your super.
Which one suits you
- Choose Australian Ethical if you want the lower fees on these figures, a long and regulator-tested track record, a MySuper default, and automatic insurance from age 25.
- Choose Future Super if its climate-first screening and impact focus matter most to you, you want to pick from five growth-to-moderate mixes, and you either have insurance elsewhere or will opt in.
- Look beyond both if fees are your main concern. Several large funds' sustainable options cost $306–$427 a year on $50,000, according to our ethical super funds comparison. Their screening is usually lighter than either specialist's, so compare the exclusion lists. That's the main answer to "Future Super alternatives".
Before switching, check whether you'd lose insurance in your current fund, and consider salary sacrifice to make the most of whichever fund you choose. Our salary sacrifice guide explains how.
Advertisement
Frequently asked questions
Is Australian Ethical or Future Super cheaper?
Australian Ethical, on their 1 November 2026 PDSs. Its Balanced option costs $653 a year on a $50,000 balance against $710 for Future Super's Sustainable Balanced Growth, and $1,238 against $1,360 on $100,000. The gap grows with your balance because Future Super's percentage fees are higher (1.30% against 1.17% a year).
Did Future Super pass the APRA performance test?
Future Super's options aren't subject to the test. APRA classifies them as externally directed products, where the trustee doesn't set the asset allocation, and these sit outside the annual performance test. Australian Ethical's MySuper option is tested and passed in 2026, with a 10-year return of 7.51% a year to 30 June 2026.
Does Future Super include insurance?
Not by default. Future Super's insurance is opt-in: eligible members can apply for death, TPD and income protection cover. Australian Ethical gives default death and TPD cover once you're 25 or older and your balance reaches $6,000.
What does Future Super avoid investing in?
Its PDS says its investment manager seeks to avoid fossil fuels, gambling, tobacco, nuclear and weapons. It also uses positive screening, impact investing and stewardship. The full detail is in Future Super's Product & Screening Matrix.
How long has Future Super's current option range existed?
All five current options (Sustainable Moderate, Balanced Growth, Alternatives Growth, Growth and High Growth) launched on 24 May 2025, when earlier options such as Balanced Index closed. That's why there are no three-, five- or ten-year returns for them yet.
Who owns Future Super?
Future Super is a product in the Smart Future Trust. Its trustee is Stewarda Pty Ltd, and the promoter and investment manager are part of Future Group. Australian Ethical's trustee is a wholly owned subsidiary of Australian Ethical Investment Ltd, which is listed on the ASX.
Related calculators and guides
- Superannuation Calculator: project your balance under different fee levels
- Ethical super funds compared: eight ethical and sustainable options, including big-fund alternatives
- Super fund comparison Australia
- Salary sacrifice guide
- Ethical ETFs: VESG vs ETHI vs VETH vs FAIR
This article is for general information only and does not constitute financial, tax or legal advice. Individual circumstances vary. Consult a registered tax agent or licensed financial adviser before making decisions based on this information.
Written by
Mahi PatilSoftware engineer & personal finance enthusiast · Melbourne, Australia
Built Dolaro.com.au to create accurate, free Australian finance tools. Invests in Australian and global ETFs and writes about the topics researched firsthand. More about Mahi →